---
title: "Substack Alternative: NeetoMemberly vs Substack"
description: "NeetoMemberly vs Substack: Substack keeps 10% of every paid subscription, plus Stripe's fees. NeetoMemberly keeps 0.5%, with unlimited members and your own Stripe account."
canonical_url: "https://www.neeto.com/neetomemberly/compare/substack-alternative"
markdown_url: "https://www.neeto.com/neetomemberly/compare/substack-alternative.md"
---

# Substack Alternative: NeetoMemberly vs Substack

NeetoMemberly vs Substack: Substack keeps 10% of every paid subscription, plus Stripe's fees. NeetoMemberly keeps 0.5%, with unlimited members and your own Stripe account.

## Overview

Substack keeps 10% of every subscription. NeetoMemberly keeps 0.5%.

Substack is free to publish on, but it keeps 10% of every paid subscription, and Stripe's fees come on top. Subscriptions bought in its iPhone app also lose Apple's cut. NeetoMemberly keeps 0.5% of what you collect, and payments go straight into your own Stripe account.

-   $25: NeetoMemberly's cost on $5,000 a month in subscriptions
-   $500: Substack's 10% on the same $5,000
-   $5,700: What you keep in a year by switching, at $5,000 a month

## Where Substack charges more, NeetoMemberly charges 0.5%.

Here's exactly what changes when you switch

Substack is a great place to start writing and its network can bring readers. But the 10% never goes away, however big your publication gets. Here's the honest difference.

## Key differences

### 10% of every subscription, or 0.5%

Substack keeps 10% of paid subscription revenue, then Stripe takes its processing fee. NeetoMemberly keeps 0.5%. On a $10 monthly subscription, that's $1 to Substack against 5¢ to NeetoMemberly, from every subscriber, every month.

-   NeetoMemberly: 0.5% per payment. Twenty times less than Substack's cut.
-   Substack: 10% per payment. Plus Stripe's fees, on every renewal.

### A bigger audience shouldn't mean a bigger cut

At $20,000 a month in subscriptions, Substack keeps $2,000 a month, or $24,000 a year. NeetoMemberly costs $100 a month. The more successful your publication, the more the 10% costs you.

-   NeetoMemberly: $100 at $20,000 a month. 0.5%, however big you get.
-   Substack: $2,000 at $20,000 a month. 10%, however big you get.

### No Apple cut on your subscribers

Substack turns on in-app purchases in its iPhone app for every paid publication, and creators can't switch them off. Apple takes up to 30% of those, and Substack still takes its 10%. With NeetoMemberly, members pay through Stripe on the web, at Stripe's standard rate.

-   NeetoMemberly: Stripe on the web. Members pay you directly.
-   Substack: In-app purchases always on. Apple's 15–30% applies to app sign-ups.

### Free members and trials cost you nothing

A big free list is how most memberships grow. NeetoMemberly charges only on payments you collect, so free members, free plans and free trials are always free to you, however many you have.

-   NeetoMemberly: Free members · $0. Grow the free list as large as you like.
-   Substack: Free subscribers included. Substack doesn't charge for free subscribers either, but every paid one pays 10%.

### Where Substack does more

Substack is a newsletter platform with a reader network: recommendations, a popular app and an editor built for writing. If you need email publishing and discovery, that's what you're paying 10% for. NeetoMemberly is for selling memberships and gating content, not sending newsletters.

-   NeetoMemberly: Memberships and payments, done well. Plans, renewals, gated content and member management for 0.5%.
-   Substack: Newsletters, app and discovery. A publishing network, for 10% of subscription revenue.

## So… what's the catch?

Fair question. 0.5% sounds too low next to the Substack bill you're used to. There's no catch: NeetoMemberly is built by Neeto (BigBinary), a profitable, 100% self-funded company that runs a whole suite of products and doesn't need to take a big cut of your members' money. You pay 0.5% of what you collect, plus Stripe's standard processing fee, which goes to Stripe. No monthly plan, no member limits, no admin seats to buy, no tier to upgrade to. If you collect nothing in a month, you pay nothing that month. Read our pricing philosophy.

-   0.5%: Our only charge, on payments you collect
-   $0: Monthly fee, setup fee and per-member fee
-   Unlimited: Members, admins and membership plans

## NeetoMemberly vs Substack, line by line

-   Monthly fee: NeetoMemberly — None; Substack — $0
-   Cut of every payment: NeetoMemberly — 0.5%; Substack — 10%
-   Cost at $5,000/month in payments: NeetoMemberly — $25; Substack — $500
-   Cost at $20,000/month in payments: NeetoMemberly — $100; Substack — $2,000
-   Price rises as your audience grows: NeetoMemberly — No; Substack — No
-   Members: NeetoMemberly — Unlimited; Substack — Unlimited
-   Admins: NeetoMemberly — Unlimited; Substack — Not stated
-   Features locked to higher plans: NeetoMemberly — None; Substack — None
-   Getting started: NeetoMemberly — Free until you get paid; Substack — Free to start
-   Payment processing: NeetoMemberly — Stripe's standard fee; Substack — Stripe fees, and Apple's cut on app sign-ups

Disclaimer: Prices and limits are from each provider's public pricing page as of November 2026 and exclude payment processing unless stated. Worked examples assume a membership collecting $5,000 or $20,000 a month. Pricing changes, so please check the provider's official pricing page for the latest numbers.

## One price: 0.5% of what you collect

Every feature, unlimited members and unlimited admins. You pay only when your members pay you.

### Substack on $5,000 a month: $500

a month · 10% of subscriptions

-   $500 platform fee (10%)
-   Plus Stripe's processing fee
-   Plus Stripe's recurring billing fee
-   Apple's cut on in-app sign-ups

### NeetoMemberly on the same $5,000: $25

a month · 0.5% · no subscription

-   All features included
-   Unlimited members
-   Unlimited admins
-   No monthly subscription
-   No setup fees

On $5,000 a month in subscriptions, Substack keeps $6,000 a year. NeetoMemberly costs $300 a year. Both exclude Stripe's processing fee.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Is NeetoMemberly a good Substack alternative?

For paid memberships, yes. Substack keeps 10% of every paid subscription; NeetoMemberly keeps 0.5%. NeetoMemberly isn't a newsletter tool, though: if you need email publishing and Substack's reader network, Substack does more. If you need to sell memberships and gate content, NeetoMemberly costs far less.

### How much does Substack take?

As of November 2026, Substack is free to publish on and keeps 10% of paid subscription revenue. Stripe's processing and recurring billing fees come on top. Subscriptions bought through Substack's iPhone app also pay Apple's in-app purchase fee.

### What does NeetoMemberly's 0.5% cover?

Everything. The 0.5% is NeetoMemberly's only charge, and it gives you every feature, unlimited members and unlimited admins. There is no monthly subscription, no setup fee and no higher plan to upgrade to. Stripe charges its own standard processing fee separately, at the rate on your Stripe account.

### Do free members or free trials cost anything?

No. NeetoMemberly charges only on payments you collect, so free members, free plans and free trials cost you nothing, however many you have.

### How do I move my members from Substack?

Export your members from Substack as a CSV file and import them into NeetoMemberly. Set up your plans, connect your Stripe account and put your members-only content behind the right plans. Because there's no monthly fee, you can set everything up and test it before you move a single paying member.

## Links

-   [Human page](https://www.neeto.com/neetomemberly/compare/substack-alternative)
